Introducing the RBL Framework

Structured spatial UI design for XR

Intuition alone won't ensure comfort, focus, and safety. This framework is based on research and built for practitioners.
Explore the framework
RBL Framework overview: semantic role, spatial behaviour, lifecycle

The RBL Framework describes each UI element through three complementary questions: Why does it exist? How does it behave in space? When does it appear?

Semantic role answers that first question, because meaning and purpose have to be established before spatial behaviour and lifecycle can be designed. Asking ‘why’ consistently keeps the user's experience central to every design decision, reducing unnecessary cognitive load.

Example scenario:

Pedestrian navigation

When finding your way through an unfamiliar city, there's a lot to take in. This intentionally minimal UI stays out of the way, allowing the user to keep their focus on the surroundings.

Navigating to destination

Walking the streets is an ongoing task, rarely urgent. Directional cues are glanceable, and points of interest appear when they are nearby and relevant.

Pedestrian navigating a narrow street with AR annotations

Point of interest

Semantic roleIdentifies a destination
Spatial behaviourStays with the destination while remaining easy to read
LifecycleVisible while nearby

Next turn indicator

Semantic roleIndicates the next navigation action
Spatial behaviourRemains in view without moving
LifecycleTemporarily hidden during route selection

The street ahead is congested

Here the planned route is blocked by a crowd, so the UI presents an alternate route. The Next turn indicator is hidden to keep the decision point in focus.

Crowded street with an alternate route suggested by AR annotations

Alternate route

Semantic rolePresents a less congested route
Spatial behaviourMarks the start of the alternative route while remaining legible
LifecycleAppears only when rerouting is needed and disappears once a route is selected

Distance indicator

Semantic roleContinuous navigation guidance
Spatial behaviourRemains in view without moving
LifecycleVisible throughout navigation

From individual elements to complex systems

While the framework helps designers reason about individual UI elements, its real strength lies in understanding how they work together as a system, and in helping designers prioritise information as the user's task changes.

Example scenario:

Driving on a highway

A car HUD shares space with an environment where attention errors carry real consequences. It directly affects the driver's ability to react.

Normal driving

Just cruising along. Information in the HUD is prioritised and organised. Some UI elements are always present, while others appear only when specific systems are active.

Driver view of a motorway with a head-up display showing speed, navigation and status information

A hazard is detected

A truck merges right in front. When the situation becomes safety-critical, lower-priority UI elements are removed to focus attention on high-consequence information.

Rainy motorway view with a reduced head-up display highlighting a braking hazard ahead

So, the hazard changes priorities across the whole HUD. How can the interface be designed to respond as a system?

Mapping the system

Semantic role, describing an element's meaning and purpose, is made up of two parts: context and consequence level. Context identifies which part of the experience an element belongs to: the system, the task, or the physical world. Consequence level shows how much priority that element should have, and can shift as situations change.

Mapping UI elements by both forms the Semantic Role Matrix, revealing patterns in the system no single element can show on its own.

Example state: Normal driving

High consequence

Shell

Task

Speed, persistent

World

Spatial: Hazard, temporary, disabled
Audio: Hazard, temporary, disabled

Medium consequence

Shell

Task

Speed limit, persistent
ACC status, persistent
Navigation next, temporary
ACC distance, temporary

World

Proximity alert, temporary

Low consequence

Shell

Battery & range, persistent
Time, persistent

Task

World

Temperature, persistent
Weather, persistent

Shell UI relates to the system's state and configuration.

Task UI supports the current task without being tied to the system or the physical location.

World UI depends contextually on something in the physical environment.

Switch between application states to compare how UI priorities change.

Always-on
Temporary (On-demand or Contextual)

Greyed-out UI elements are inactive or hidden in the current state.

The matrix clarifies design priorities, making them easier to discuss with the team and explain to stakeholders.

Next: The full framework

The examples above showed why prioritisation matters in practice. The Framework page shows in detail how every UI element can be described through semantic role, spatial behaviour, and lifecycle.

Speed

Shows the vehicle's current speed.

Modalities:
Visual

Semantic role

Context:Task
Consequence:High

Spatial behaviour

Anchoring:User (Vehicle)
Adaptations:None

In automotive interfaces, the vehicle can act as the user's reference frame.

Lifecycle

Trigger:Always-on
Duration:Persistent

Next manoeuvre spatial marker

Marks the location of the next manoeuvre.

Modalities:
Visual

Semantic role

Context:Task
Consequence:Medium → High

Consequence level increases as the manoeuvre approaches.

Spatial behaviour

Anchoring:World (Position)
Adaptations:Orientation, Scale

Lifecycle

Trigger:Contextual
Duration:Persistent

Active until the manoeuvre is made.

Hazard alert

Draws attention to a detected hazard using coordinated visual, auditory, and haptic cues.

Modalities:
VisualAuditoryHaptic

Semantic role

Context:Shell
Consequence:Medium → High

Consequence level adjusts to the severity of the hazard.

Spatial behaviour

Anchoring:User (Vehicle)
Adaptations:Orientation

In automotive interfaces, the vehicle can act as the user's reference frame. Visual and auditory cues are directional.

Lifecycle

Trigger:Contextual
Duration:Persistent

Active while the hazard is present.